|
Bolt Chrono Test III
It's time for Bolt Chrono Test 3!!!
As always this test consists of aftermarket
bolts. This time nine bolts were tested. Like Bolt Chrono Test
2, the Stock bolt was not used
in the comparison. After all, everyone knows that any aftermarket bolt
is better than the stock aluminum bolt.
The Test
For this test a stock Adrenalin Impulse was used.
The setup consisted of the following:
- The entire gun was cleaned and lubed, prior to
the test.
- Although fairly new, the Adrenalin
Impulse has seen several cases of paint so the reg and all parts are
broken in.
- The Dwell was not adjusted once the test started.
- The output
pressure on the max-flow was set at 175psi.
- For the test the air
source was a Smart Parts Low Pressure Max-Flow compressed air tank running on gun.
- The paint used
in the test was a generic "practice paint". This paint was
not consistent in size and in the test results the variance shows.
- The barrel was a 14" Freak with a .684 insert.
- Before each first shot was recorded two
clearing shots were taken.
- The bolts were tested in the order
listed below. The first 10 shots were recorded, then the bolt
was switched. After the last bolt was tested, I returned to the
first bolt and recorded the second 10 shots. This was done to
ensure that no one bolt go fresher paint from the top of the bag
or any other anomalies that might have happened.
- Paint was fed into the marker by an
Evolution II.
- The same Chronograph was used to record
the velocity of all shots.
| Table 1: Shots
recorded with each bolt. |
| |
1 |
2 |
3 |
4 |
5 |
6 |
7 |
8 |
9 |
10 |
11 |
12 |
13 |
14 |
15 |
16 |
17 |
18 |
19 |
20 |
| Adrenalin |
235 |
232 |
239 |
244 |
234 |
237 |
246 |
231 |
237 |
243 |
238 |
242 |
234 |
227 |
238 |
240 |
236 |
240 |
240 |
245 |
| Demonic
Roar |
251 |
251 |
246 |
256 |
254 |
252 |
247 |
249 |
246 |
255 |
252 |
251 |
255 |
256 |
255 |
247 |
246 |
254 |
252 |
255 |
| DEZign
Openface |
253 |
251 |
254 |
248 |
251 |
259 |
255 |
258 |
262 |
265 |
268 |
262 |
263 |
266 |
262 |
263 |
264 |
258 |
263 |
261 |
| DEZign
Venturi |
268 |
270 |
261 |
267 |
259 |
264 |
259 |
260 |
266 |
265 |
268 |
265 |
269 |
267 |
271 |
261 |
267 |
257 |
268 |
264 |
| Equalizer |
286 |
281 |
270 |
280 |
275 |
274 |
278 |
269 |
281 |
279 |
275 |
275 |
273 |
281 |
275 |
272 |
282 |
276 |
277 |
282 |
| IPB
Werm |
272 |
266 |
266 |
269 |
271 |
272 |
265 |
271 |
270 |
267 |
271 |
265 |
271 |
276 |
271 |
274 |
262 |
268 |
275 |
266 |
| IPB
Undertow |
264 |
265 |
264 |
274 |
270 |
274 |
265 |
281 |
282 |
267 |
270 |
271 |
272 |
280 |
278 |
261 |
281 |
282 |
281 |
270 |
| MAXair |
267 |
255 |
264 |
259 |
263 |
266 |
258 |
266 |
259 |
259 |
250 |
259 |
266 |
267 |
257 |
264 |
269 |
264 |
263 |
270 |
| VooDoo |
256 |
254 |
263 |
249 |
262 |
267 |
265 |
255 |
265 |
264 |
252 |
262 |
261 |
264 |
262 |
262 |
265 |
266 |
267 |
266 |
| Table 2: Statistics for each bolt
based on the data in Table 1 |
| |
Average |
STD |
MIN |
MAX |
MIN/MAX
range |
Avg
-Min/Max |
| Adrenalin |
237.90 |
4.77 |
227 |
246 |
19 |
238.06 |
| Demonic
Roar |
251.50 |
3.47 |
246 |
256 |
10 |
251.56 |
| DEZign
Openface |
259.30 |
5.46 |
248 |
268 |
20 |
259.44 |
| DEZign
Venturi |
264.80 |
3.94 |
257 |
271 |
14 |
264.89 |
| Equalizer |
277.05 |
4.32 |
269 |
286 |
17 |
277.00 |
| IPB
Werm |
269.40 |
3.60 |
262 |
276 |
14 |
269.44 |
| IPB
Undertow |
272.60 |
6.81 |
261 |
282 |
21 |
272.72 |
| MAXair |
262.25 |
4.97 |
250 |
270 |
20 |
262.50 |
| VooDoo |
261.35 |
5.14 |
249 |
267 |
18 |
261.72 |
Results:
Average FPS
|
Average |
Score |
| Equalizer |
277.05 |
1 |
| IPB
Undertow |
272.60 |
2 |
| IPB
Werm |
269.40 |
3 |
| DEZign
Venturi |
264.80 |
4 |
| MAXair |
262.25 |
5 |
| VooDoo |
261.35 |
6 |
| DEZign
Openface |
259.30 |
7 |
| Demonic
Roar |
251.50 |
8 |
| Adrenalin |
237.90 |
9 |
The Equalizer had the largest increase in velocity
over all other bolts. The IPB Undertow was second and the IPB Werm
bolt was third.
What is interesting here is that in the last bolt
test, the Equalizer bolt was third, the top two positions
were held by the DEZign bolts. In this test both DEZign bolts did not perform
as well. I attribute this to the cut of the Adrenalin
Impulse. When installing both of the DEZign bolts it was noticeable
that the bolts fit much tighter than the others, possibly almost too
tight.
Standard Deviation
|
STD |
Score |
| Demonic Roar |
3.47 |
1 |
| IPB Werm |
3.60 |
2 |
| DEZign Venturi |
3.94 |
3 |
| Equalizer |
4.32 |
4 |
| Adrenalin |
4.77 |
5 |
| MAXair |
4.97 |
6 |
| VooDoo |
5.14 |
7 |
| DEZign Openface |
5.46 |
8 |
| IPB Undertow |
6.81 |
9 |
The Demonic Roar, new comer to the Bolt Chrono Test,
was the most consistent bolt, having the least amount of standard
deviation. The IPB Werm bolt was second, followed by the DEZign
Venturi bolt.
As I mentioned earlier, the paint I was using was not
the best, but I elected to use it anyway as often people do not have the
luxury of choosing the paint they shoot. I believe this is the primary
reason that the consistency results are as high or poor as they are.
Best Performance
Taking the scores from Average FPS and
Standard Deviation and adding them together we should be able to see
which bolt is the best all around bolt from this test.
|
Average |
STD |
Score |
| Equalizer |
1 |
4 |
5 |
| IPB Werm |
3 |
2 |
5 |
| DEZign Venturi |
4 |
3 |
7 |
| Demonic Roar |
8 |
1 |
9 |
| IPB Undertow |
2 |
9 |
11 |
| MAXair |
5 |
6 |
11 |
| VooDoo |
6 |
7 |
13 |
| Adrenalin |
9 |
5 |
14 |
| DEZign Openface |
7 |
8 |
15 |
Conclusion
For overall performance, which is a balance between
efficiency and consistency, the Equalizer and IPB Werm bolt tied for the
top position. Followed by the DEZign Venturi bolt.
My biggest surprise was that the Adrenalin bolt did not
perform well in an Adrenalin Impulse. In reality the Adrenalin bolt
was the least efficient in my Adrenalin Impulse and was the second lowest
overall scoring bolt.
Comparing the results of this test to the
previous test, it is hard to draw a conclusion as to which bolt is truly
better. While some of the bolts performed consistently well, like
the Equalizer the IPB Werm, which had the lowest score in Bolt Chrono Test
2, performed exceptionally well.
Lesson learned:
Every Impulse is different. An upgrade that performs exceptional in
my testing might not perform as well in your Impulse. Keep in mind
that there are many variables that can effect how various parts perform in
your Impulse. My tests should be used as a baseline for comparison,
not the end all be all decision making factor.
Special thanks to Derrek "SG"
Phelps from Team Chill Factor for once again hanging out and recording the numbers while I
shoot my
Impulse over the chrono. |